The Broadway scene is booming since, despite the vast expense, it is often a must on any tourist’s itinerary. There are plenty of shows to choose from, some are easier to get tickets for than others. If you’re interested in Book of Mormon, Matilda or Kinky Boots, prepare to beg, borrow or steal a ticket because otherwise you won’t get a seat. Prices reflect popularity and trends.

Mamma Mia is one of the few famous musicals I have never seen, so I enthusiastically took the opportunity to see the show in New York. This feel-good musical is currently on stage at the Broadhurst Theatre, one of the many glittering establishments amongst the bright lights of Times Square.

This classic ABBA musical, with music and lyrics by Benny Andersson and Bjorn Ulvaeus, is a back-to-back medley of the familiar 80s songs. You can’t help but sing along. The production itself is unspectacular, the set feels tired and the volume from the singers needs a boost. I wanted to be blown away by this big Broadway show, but I just wasn’t.

The orchestra seem to enjoy the upbeat score, conducted by a cheerful Wendy Bobbitt Cavett. Judy McLane succeeds vocally as Donna Sheridan but doesn’t engage well with the audience, her eyes have a glazed look and dramatically she is rather robotic. Laurie Veldheer is better as the daughter, Sophie, and her friends provide some comedy.

Since the film hit the big screen, Mamma Mia the musical has struggled to be as impressive on stage and sadly the current Broadway cast seem resigned to their inferior position.